Who to Keep in this Money League?

[Adam]

Straight keeper league, so rounds do not matter. Standard scoring except no PPR, 6 pts per TD, and the following bonuses: 2 pts for 350 yard passing and 3 points for 400 yards passing; 2 points for 150 rushing and 3 points for 200 rushing; 2 points for 150 receiving and 3 for 175 receiving

Bold are my thoughts

QB: Matt Schaub, Jay Cutler
RB: AD, Beanie Wells, JStew, Portis, Chester Taylor
WR: Steve Smith (CAR), Ochocinco, MSW, Mike Wallace, Chambers, Massaquoi
TE: Fred Davis, James Casey


Also, I have the second pick in the draft, which I likely will be using on Dez Bryant

[BlueBandit24]

I would keep Steve Smith over MSW. I feel Moore is just good enough to get Smiff back into the Top 10 and he's still an elite talent. I don't trust MSW's talent nor situation enough to keep over Smith at this point. Other than, I agree with your choices.

[Adam]

I would keep Steve Smith over MSW. I feel Moore is just good enough to get Smiff back into the Top 10 and he's still an elite talent. I don't trust MSW's talent nor situation enough to keep over Smith at this point. Other than, I agree with your choices.

That was my first thought, but then I read over some of our rankings and changed my mind.

[treat24]

I would keep Steve Smith over MSW. I feel Moore is just good enough to get Smiff back into the Top 10 and he's still an elite talent. I don't trust MSW's talent nor situation enough to keep over Smith at this point. Other than, I agree with your choices.

That was my first thought, but then I read over some of our rankings and changed my mind.

A. Those need updating as I like Nicks more than Smith (NYG)
B. I don't like Steve Smith (CAR) so that probably factored in. Just like I don't ever like Lee Evans or Santana Moss.
C. I have those two fairly close but think that Steve Smith is safer. I really like Moore.

The Rankings will be updated again soon and we'll have a new layout with multiple rankings within the next few weeks

[LoveBoatCaptain]

I think Steve Smith needs to be the pick. I think he's the better WR and your scoring that rewards big games furthers his value over MSW.

[Kilroy]

Steve Smith would break your jaw for even considering not keeping him.

Of course, then you could sue.